米兰体育

Skip to content
NOWCAST 米兰体育 13 6am Newscast
Watch on Demand
Advertisement

State of Shopping: The future of malls and shopping centers in Central Alabama

State of Shopping: The future of malls and shopping centers in Central Alabama
INVESTIGATION INTO THE RISE AND FALL OF MALLS IN CENTRAL ALABAMA. 米兰体育 13 SCOTT CARPENTER HAS SPENT MONTHS LOOKING INTO SEVERAL MALLS AND SHOPPING CENTERS IN OUR STATE. YEAH, HE TALKS WITH A BUSINESS CONSULTANT AND MALL OWNERS AND RETAIL DEVELOPERS ABOUT THE CURRENT STATE OF SHOPPING. OVER THE PAST WEEK, WE鈥橵E DISCUSSED MALLS THAT ARE NO LONGER STANDING, LIKE EASTWOOD MALL AND CENTURY PLAZA. THE EAST SIDE OF BIRMINGHAM WANTS A SHOPPER鈥橲 PARADISE, MAKING IT ONE OF THE TOP RETAIL DESTINATIONS IN THE COUNTRY. DECADES AGO. BUT WHAT REALLY LED TO THE COLLAPSE OF THESE PROMINENT INDOOR MALLS? DOCTOR BOB ROBICHAUX, A BUSINESS CONSULTANT AND RETIRED MARKETING PROFESSOR, SAYS THEY FAILED TO CHANGE WITH THE TIMES. THE EASTWOOD MALL WAS CRITICIZED FOR JUST HAVING GOTTEN OUT OF TOUCH WITH WITH THE INDUSTRY THAT THEY WEREN鈥橳 WILLING TO INNOVATE AND CHANGE THE WAY THEY DO THINGS AND BROOKWOOD VILLAGE AND HOMEWOOD ONCE THRIVING, NOW EMPTY. WHAT LED TO THE DECLINE OF BROOKWOOD TO WHERE IT SITS NOW? I THINK THAT PEOPLE鈥橲 HABITS CHANGED, AND I THINK THAT PEOPLE DIDN鈥橳 HAVE THE TIME TO MAYBE PULL UP INTO A PARKING SPACE, GET OUT OF THEIR CAR, GO INTO A MALL. AND I THINK SOME OF THE OTHER ALTERNATIVES WHERE THEY COULD JUST PULL RIGHT UP TO A DOOR THAT THEY鈥橰E GOING TO AND GO INSIDE, BECAME MORE ATTRACTIVE. HOMEWOOD CITY COUNCILWOMAN JENNIFER ANDREWS IS REALLY REFERRING TO THE SUMMIT. THERE, AND THE OWNERS OF THE SUMMIT SAY THEIR BUSINESS IS THRIVING. THEY SAY BEING AN OPEN AIR SHOPPING CENTER WHERE CUSTOMERS CAN HAVE AN EXPERIENCE THAT SETS THEM APART. THEY HAVE STORES UNIQUE TO ALABAMA, PLACES TO EAT AND ENTERTAINMENT OPTIONS LIKE AMC THEATER. MIKE WHITE IS NOW IN THE RETAIL BUSINESS, BUT USED TO BE THE MANAGER OF RIVERCHASE GALLERIA. HE SAYS THE SUMMIT WAS UNBEATABLE. COMPETITION. THE SUMMIT PROPERTY IS, YOU KNOW, THEY鈥橰E THEIR PRACTICE IN COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE ON A LEVEL THAT VERY FEW PEOPLE ANYWHERE IN THE UNITED STATES ARE DOING. THEIR SUCCESS IS THEY鈥橰E AMAZING. BUT HOW ARE THEY THRIVING WHEN ONLINE SHOPPING IS SO POPULAR? DOCTOR ROBICHAUX SAYS THEIR OUTDOOR SHOPPING CENTER FITS IN WITH TODAY鈥橲 BUSY LIFESTYLE. HE ALSO CREDITS THE SUMMIT鈥橲 ONE BAG ONLINE SHOPPING EXPERIENCE, WHERE PEOPLE CAN SHOP MULTIPLE STORES THAT ARE AT THE SUMMIT ONLINE AND GET THEIR ORDER LATER THAT DAY. THEY SET UP AN OPERATION THAT ALLOWED ALL OF THE MERCHANTS TO GO TO THAT SAME PLATFORM AND IF THERE WAS A SINGLE CUSTOMER ON A GIVEN DAY MAKING ANY PURCHASE AT MULTIPLE STORES, THEY WOULD ALL BE PLACED IN A COMMON CART SO THAT THEY COULD BE DELIVERED AT ONE TIME. THE REALITY IS, ALL STORES HAVE TO ADAPT IN THIS ERA OF ONLINE SHOPPING. EVEN SOCIAL MEDIA SITES ARE COMPETITORS NOW, LIKE THE TIKTOK SHOP. DOCTOR ROBICHAUX SAYS ONLINE SALES WERE GOING UP EVEN BEFORE THE PANDEMIC. BUT HE SAYS MALLS AREN鈥橳 DEAD. THEY JUST NEED TO REINVENT THEMSELVES. WHAT THEY鈥橰E GOING TO HAVE TO CHANGE. THERE鈥橲 AN INDUSTRY LIFE CYCLE CONCEPT, AND MOST PEOPLE WHO STUDY RETAILING WOULD SAY THE MALLS ARE IN THE DECLINE STAGE, AND WE MIGHT BE SEEING SOME PROGRESS AS SO MANY MALLS ACROSS THE COUNTRY HAVE STARTED CHANGING. PLACER.AI, A COMPANY THAT PROVIDES LOCATION ANALYTICS, SAYS OVER THE PAST YEAR, FOOT TRAFFIC AT INDOOR MALLS IS UP 8.6%. OUTDOOR SHOPPING CENTERS SEEING A 6% BOOST IN TRAFFIC AND OUTLET MALLS UP MORE THAN 5%. MORE PEOPLE NOW GOING TO MALLS, BUT RETAILERS WILL NEED THEM TO OPEN UP THEIR WALLETS. ROBICHAUX SAYS RESEARCH INDICATES NATIONWIDE MALL SALES REVENUE IS DOWN 4% PER YEAR SINCE 2019. EMPLOYEES DOWN 5.5% PER YEAR OVER THAT SAME TIME PERIOD, AND THE NUMBER OF MALLS DOWN 3% PER YEAR SINCE 2019. NOW FOR MORE ON OUR INVESTIGATION INTO THE RISE AND FALL OF MALLS IN CENTRAL ALABAMA, JUST VISIT OUR WEBSITE OR THE 米兰体育 APP. YOU CAN FIND ALL THE STORIES WE DID OVER THE COURSE OF OUR MONTHS LONG INVESTIGATION.
Advertisement
State of Shopping: The future of malls and shopping centers in Central Alabama
CLICK HERE TO GO BACK TO FULL SERIES PAGE A monthslong 米兰体育 13 investigation into the rise and fall of malls in Central Alabama has shown the changing retail landscape. Birmingham was once a top retail destination in the U.S., with two of the largest malls in the country, Eastwood Mall and Century Plaza, sitting side by side.Eastwood Mall closed in 2004, followed by Century Plaza closing in 2009."Eastwood Mall was criticized for having gotten out of touch with the industry that they weren't willing to innovate and change the way they do things," says Bob Robicheaux, a business consultant and retired marketing professor.Brookwood VillageOnce-thriving Brookwood Village in Homewood now stands empty."What led to the decline of Brookwood to where it sits now?" 米兰体育 13's Scott Carpenter asked."I think people's habits changed," said Homewood City Councilor Jennifer Andress. "People didn't have the time to pull up to a parking space, get out of their car, go into a mall, and I think some of the other alternatives where they can just pull right up to a door that they're going to and go inside became more attractive."The SummitThe Summit, an open-air shopping center, thrives by offering a unique shopping experience with stores, dining, and entertainment options like AMC Theatre."The Summit is practicing commercial real estate on a level that very few people anywhere around the United States are doing. Their success is amazing," says Mike White, the former manager of Riverchase Galleria.Robicheaux attributes The Summit's success to its outdoor shopping center model and the "One Bag" online shopping experience, where customers can shop multiple stores online and receive their order the same day."They set up an operation that allowed all merchants to go to the same platform, and if there was a single customer making purchases at multiple stores, they would all be placed in a common cart so they could be delivered at one time," said Robicheaux.Time for reinventionDespite the rise of online shopping, Robicheaux believes malls are not dead but need to reinvent themselves."They're going to have to change. There's an industry lifecycle concept. Most people who study retailing would say malls are in the decline stage," said Robicheaux.Recent data from Placer.ai shows a positive trend, with foot traffic at indoor malls up 8.6% from 2022 to 2023, outdoor shopping centers seeing a 6% boost, and outlet malls up more than 5%. 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't see the graphic? Click here.However, Robicheaux says nationwide mall sales revenue has decreased by 4% per year since 2019, with employee numbers down 5.5% per year and the number of malls down 3% per year over the same period. Retailers will need shoppers to open up their wallets to change this trend.

CLICK HERE TO GO BACK TO FULL SERIES PAGE

Advertisement

A monthslong 米兰体育 13 investigation into the rise and fall of malls in Central Alabama has shown the changing retail landscape.

Birmingham was once a top retail destination in the U.S., with two of the largest malls in the country, Eastwood Mall and Century Plaza, sitting side by side.

Eastwood Mall closed in 2004, followed by Century Plaza closing in 2009.

"Eastwood Mall was criticized for having gotten out of touch with the industry that they weren't willing to innovate and change the way they do things," says Bob Robicheaux, a business consultant and retired marketing professor.

Brookwood Village

Once-thriving Brookwood Village in Homewood now stands empty.

"What led to the decline of Brookwood to where it sits now?" 米兰体育 13's Scott Carpenter asked.

"I think people's habits changed," said Homewood City Councilor Jennifer Andress. "People didn't have the time to pull up to a parking space, get out of their car, go into a mall, and I think some of the other alternatives where they can just pull right up to a door that they're going to and go inside became more attractive."

The Summit

The Summit, an open-air shopping center, thrives by offering a unique shopping experience with stores, dining, and entertainment options like AMC Theatre.

"The Summit is practicing commercial real estate on a level that very few people anywhere around the United States are doing. Their success is amazing," says Mike White, the former manager of Riverchase Galleria.

Robicheaux attributes The Summit's success to its outdoor shopping center model and the "One Bag" online shopping experience, where customers can shop multiple stores online and receive their order the same day.

"They set up an operation that allowed all merchants to go to the same platform, and if there was a single customer making purchases at multiple stores, they would all be placed in a common cart so they could be delivered at one time," said Robicheaux.

Time for reinvention

Despite the rise of online shopping, Robicheaux believes malls are not dead but need to reinvent themselves.

"They're going to have to change. There's an industry lifecycle concept. Most people who study retailing would say malls are in the decline stage," said Robicheaux.

Recent data from Placer.ai shows a positive trend, with foot traffic at indoor malls up 8.6% from 2022 to 2023, outdoor shopping centers seeing a 6% boost, and outlet malls up more than 5%.

Can't see the graphic? Click here.

However, Robicheaux says nationwide mall sales revenue has decreased by 4% per year since 2019, with employee numbers down 5.5% per year and the number of malls down 3% per year over the same period.

Retailers will need shoppers to open up their wallets to change this trend.