米兰体育

Skip to content
NOWCAST 米兰体育 13 Morning News
Watch on Demand
Advertisement

Former prosecutor: Tony Mitchell homicide ruling suggests criminal conduct

Former prosecutor: Tony Mitchell homicide ruling suggests criminal conduct
KEY PIECE IN ANY INVESTIGATIVE PUZZLE. THE DETAILS IN TONY MITCHELL鈥橲 DEATH CERTIFICATE ARE FEW, BUT POTENTIALLY IMPACTFUL. IT CLASSIFIES HIS DEATH AS A HOMICIDE, STATING THE MAIN CAUSES AS HYPOTHERMIA AND INFECTIONS DURING INCARCERATION, WITH MEDICAL NEGLECT. A CORONER SAYS THAT THIS IS DEATH BY HOMICIDE. HE IS SAYING THAT THIS IS DEATH, NOT BY NATURAL CAUSES. UM, AND AT SOMEBODY ELSE鈥橲 HAND IN ONE WAY OR ANOTHER. MITCHELL SPENT TWO WEEKS IN THE WALKER COUNTY JAIL IN JANUARY 2023. HIS HEALTH DETERIORATED AND DEPUTIES HAD TO CARRY HIM OUT OF THE JAIL AND RUSH HIM TO THE HOSPITAL, WHERE HE WAS PRONOUNCED DEAD. FORMER U.S. ATTORNEY DOUG JONES SAYS NOT ALL HOMICIDES ARE CRIMINAL, BUT MITCHELL鈥橲 CASE IS DIFFERENT THAN JUST A FIREBALL DEATHS. WHEN SOMEONE IS DEFENDING THEMSELVES. IT鈥橲 GOING TO BE HARD TO CLAIM THAT THIS WAS JUSTIFIABLE HOMICIDE DIED, UM, IN A CASE SUCH AS TONY MITCHELL鈥橲 CASE IN WALKER COUNTY, I DON鈥橳 THINK WE鈥橰E GOING TO FIND THAT SHERIFF NICK SMITH HAS DENIED HE OR HIS STAFF WERE GUILTY OF ANY WRONGDOING. TODAY, HE SAID. RECENTLY COMPLETED AUTOPSY BRINGS US CLOSER TO UNCOVERING TRUTH BEHIND THE CASE. BUT DUE TO THE ONGOING INVESTIGATIONS, I AM UNABLE TO DISCUSS DETAILS RIGHT NOW, JONES SAID THE FBI WILL USE THE AUTOPSY TO FIGURE OUT IF MITCHELL鈥橲 CIVIL RIGHTS WERE VIOLATED, IF SOMETHING WENT WRONG UP THERE AND THAT THAT DOESN鈥橳 HAVE TO ALWAYS BE WHERE YOU ARE BEATING SOMEBODY, NEGLECT, I THINK, IN MY VIEW, CAN BE A DEPRIVATION OF CIVIL RIGHTS UNDER COLOR OF LAW. THE SIMPLE DOCUMENT IS JUST THE NEXT PIECE OF THE PUZZLE, ANSWERING WHO AND WHAT ARE TRULY TO BLAME FOR MITCHELL鈥橲 DEATH. NOW WE DID. WE DID CHECK WITH ALEA TO FIND OUT HOW THIS AUTOPSY COULD AFFECT THEIR CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION. THEY SIMPLY TOLD US THAT THEIR REVIEW IS STILL PENDING WHEN IT IS FINISHED. THOSE RESULTS, THEIR FINDINGS WILL BE TURNED OVER TO THE WALKER COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY TO DECIDE IF ANY CRIMINAL PROSECUTION WOULD BE NEEDED.
Advertisement
Former prosecutor: Tony Mitchell homicide ruling suggests criminal conduct
The details in Tony Mitchell's death certificate are few but potentially impactful. It classifies his death as a homicide, stating the main causes as hypothermia and infections during incarceration with medical neglect.鈥淭he coroner says that this is death by homicide. He is saying that this is death, not by natural causes and at somebody else's hand in one way or another,鈥� former U.S. Attorney Doug Jones said.Mitchell spent two weeks in the Walker County Jail in January 2023. His health deteriorated, and deputies had to carry him out of the jail and rush him to the hospital, where he was pronounced dead. Jones says not all homicides are criminal, but Mitchell's case is different than justifiable deaths when someone is defending themselves.>> 米兰体育 13 ON-THE-GO: Download our app for free鈥淕oing to be hard to claim that this was justifiable homicide in a case such as Tony Mitchell's case in Walker County. I don't think we're going to find that,鈥� Jones said.Sheriff Nick Smith has denied he or his staff were guilty of any wrongdoing."Recently completed autopsy brings us closer to uncovering truth behind this case, but due to the ongoing investigations I am unable to discuss details right now," Sheriff Smith said.Jones thinks the FBI can use the autopsy to figure out if Mitchell's civil rights were violated.>> FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL: Facebook | Twitter | Instagram | YouTube 鈥淪omething went wrong up there, and that that doesn't have to always be where you are beating somebody. Neglect, I think, in my view, can be a deprivation of civil rights under color of law,鈥� Jones said.The wrongful death Mitchell鈥檚 family filed in federal court against Sheriff Smith and his staff is on hold until the criminal investigations run their course. ALEA said Friday the findings of their review are still pending.

The details in Tony Mitchell's death certificate are few but potentially impactful.

It classifies his death as a homicide, stating the main causes as hypothermia and infections during incarceration with medical neglect.

Advertisement

鈥淭he coroner says that this is death by homicide. He is saying that this is death, not by natural causes and at somebody else's hand in one way or another,鈥� former U.S. Attorney Doug Jones said.

Mitchell spent two weeks in the Walker County Jail in January 2023.

His health deteriorated, and deputies had to carry him out of the jail and rush him to the hospital, where he was pronounced dead.

Jones says not all homicides are criminal, but Mitchell's case is different than justifiable deaths when someone is defending themselves.

>> 米兰体育 13 ON-THE-GO: Download our app for free

鈥淕oing to be hard to claim that this was justifiable homicide in a case such as Tony Mitchell's case in Walker County. I don't think we're going to find that,鈥� Jones said.

Sheriff Nick Smith has denied he or his staff were guilty of any wrongdoing.

"Recently completed autopsy brings us closer to uncovering truth behind this case, but due to the ongoing investigations I am unable to discuss details right now," Sheriff Smith said.

Jones thinks the FBI can use the autopsy to figure out if Mitchell's civil rights were violated.

>> FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL: | | |

鈥淪omething went wrong up there, and that that doesn't have to always be where you are beating somebody. Neglect, I think, in my view, can be a deprivation of civil rights under color of law,鈥� Jones said.

The wrongful death Mitchell鈥檚 family filed in federal court against Sheriff Smith and his staff is on hold until the criminal investigations run their course.

ALEA said Friday the findings of their review are still pending.